Ius In Bello Analysis. Words | 4 Pages. There is a debate about the justification of war. Pacifics like Walter Wink believe that nonresistance is the method of dealing with one’s adversary, and war is unjustifiable. They used the biblical references, more specifically the Matthew Section, to validate their claim War is not justifiable to remember. Does this change your mind? War is violent, although it can also at times be passive. It is described in many different ways. Most say you need to experience it to understand what it is, war can not truly be defined. War is what it is made, it is the tactics, the men and women lost, and the time period I feel that war is justified and will be looking into points that are for the justification of war. War is justified when there is a “just cause”, and when it is used as a “last resort”. In many cases however, there are corrupted individuals who only perceive that which just through their own eyes which is very subjective instead of looking from an objective perspective
Research Of How War Can Be Justified: [Essay Example], words GradesFixer
Wars can be justified through the utilitarian theory and cost benefit analysis. These are dependent on whether the intention of the war is war ever justified essay right and the cause for the war is just. Further, wars are only justified when other forms of conflict management have been tried and have failed. There are many types of war, however this essay will focus on military war in particular. Utility Theory and Just War The theory of utility is one way to justify war. The utilitarian approach is defined as the pursuit of the greatest good of society for the greatest number f people in society.
There are two branches of utility theory - act and rule. Act utilitarianism looks closely at the Consequences of the act Of war in order to justify engaging in war. Rule utilitarianism will only condone war when the reason for entering a war is just in itself, is war ever justified essay, is based on good intentions and not for selfish reasons. In essence, act utilitarianism can be summarized as the ends justifying the means, is war ever justified essay, while rule utilitarianism can be summarized as genuine intentions justifying the means. For instance, the Allied Forces declaring war on Germany's invasion of their gibbous as well as on their anti-Semitic activities is an example of utilitarianism in action. Is war ever justified essay declaration of war was to prevent further harm to the world even if it did mean a significant loss to the Allied Forces by engaging in such actions.
The end of the German terror as well as the protection Of the persecuted justified the means through which this was achieved. The distinction between act and rule utilitarianism while easily distinguishable in theory, is much harder to apply in real life. The example given above can be categorized under both types of utility theory. The protection of a large persecuted number of people justified entering into war against the anti- Semitic administration is war ever justified essay Germany. Order custom essay Is war ever justified with free plagiarism report.
Viewing it in this manner allows rule utilitarianism to come into play. At the same time, looking at the consequences of war -? which would be the saving of not only Jews, but also the prevention of invasion of other countries in Europe allows act utilitarianism to justify the Allied Forces is war ever justified essay on war on Nazi Germany. Utility theory does run the risk of being manipulated is war ever justified essay abused and has been used by terrorists and Islamic fundamentalists to justify the use of rower and force for "jihad" or what they call, "holy war".
However, it must be noted that utility theory condones war only if it causes the greatest good for the greatest number of society. Even if "jihad" is considered to be the greatest good, it is only from the perspective of a select few people with biased opinions. Hence, a terrorist's justification of war via utility theory cannot be said to be a true justification at all. Be it act or rule utilitarianism, so long as the ends is war ever justified essay in the greatest good for the largest number of people in society and are made with the best intentions in mind, war is justified. Cost-benefit Analysis and Just War The benefits should outweigh the costs in order to justify engaging in war. Cost-benefit analysis is a way of weighing the strengths and weaknesses of alternatives. It helps us determine whether an approach was worth the adoption and practice in terms of benefits in labor, time, Cost savings and so on.
It is largely considered an economic analysis and is an approach that can be taken when determining whether a war is justified because of the high socio-economic costs involved in war. A good way to go about analyzing this would be to look at a case study of the Iraq war. The Gulf war resulted inIraqi casualties and a few hundred thousand is war ever justified essay Iraqis. The costs of war amounted to 6 trillion US dollars. These numbers are neither small nor insignificant. The benefits, is war ever justified essay, however, are the exact opposite. As far as tangible benefits go, the Iraqi economy saw a slight growth in its GAP since the end of the war. Part of this, is a windfall due to high oil prices but if the war had not taken place, oil sanctions imposed on Iraq would have severely curtailed Iraqi oil sale.
This would have further crushed the already dying economy pre-war. Of course, since Cost-Benefit analysis is primarily economic in nature, is war ever justified essay, on paper, the growth in Iraq's GAP is touted by pro-war candidates as being worth the effort. However it would be ridiculous to imagine that Iraq's economy would have grown enough to cover the costs of war even, much less to actually grow enough to recover and sustain the country post-war. Further, as cost-benefit analysis also should include some elements of intangibility, one must take note Of the accessory costs that came along with the war. Besides the devastation and disease that struck Iraq, neighbors Iran also saw acceleration in its nuclear programmed because it saw that as the only way to prevent an imminent US invasion.
This is not good for the global economy because it makes the Middle East a very dangerous place. Further, there is a high continuing rate of violence in Iraq because society sees it as the only form of protection for them. Of course, regime change and the demise of Sadism Hussein must be considered in the benefit analysis but despite that, Iraq is still in shambles -? both economically as well as socially, is war ever justified essay. Overall, a cost-benefit analysis allows us another opportunity to evaluate a war and to decide if it can be justified. In the example of Iraq, we can see how it can be used to prove that it cannot be justified. Counter argument However, despite these two analytical methods of justifying war, they come with a caveat.
The caveat being that they are only used to justify war when negotiations have failed between parties; all peaceful methods have been already exhausted and war is the final and only option available to them. Unfortunately, this is not always the case. Many a time, countries prepare for war while negotiations are ongoing. Worse still, they may not even engage in any peaceful forms of collaboration or settlement at all. The notions of war always remain at the back of countries' minds. The Cold War may seem like a successful instance where there were no missiles or bombs unloaded on either the USSR or the US.
However, there was a war nonetheless and a war which lasted 30 years. Despite supposed 'peaceful' negotiations between the two superpowers, the thought of missile warfare was always at the back of their minds. It would not be far-fetched to imagine that this severely impacted the success Of their discussions. One cannot fully and calmly negotiate with a finger on the trigger. It was merely a combination of luck, timing and the right set of leaders that prevented the outbreak of a disastrous third world war. Conclusion War can be justified through two methods - utility theory and cost-benefit analysis. These allow an intangible and tangible account of the ways in which a war can is war ever justified essay explained as being necessary. This essay was written by a fellow student.
You can use it as an example when writing your own essay or use it as a source, but you need cite it. Explore how the human body functions as one unit in harmony in order to life. Is war ever justified. Free Essays - PhDessay. com, is war ever justified essay, Apr 07, Accessed April 18, comApr Globalization is one of the most vibrant, contested, and debated issues in modern international relations. Some argue that globalization brings great benefits, while others argue that globalization is fundamentally flawed. Justified and ancient. Throughout the years, the modern world has had an enormous impact on third world countries, where we continually influence them on different levels. Whether or not this. Were the Americans justified in dropping the atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki in August ?
The dropping of the atomic bomb on Nagasaki and Hiroshima in by the. The sole purpose in the role of the country is to protect the citizens of the nation; that is exactly what Great Britain did for its nation and for the. Justified wage for a worker refers to the wage level that considers a worker in a need based criterion. It is the wage that can cater for daily needs not. Insider trading is a threat to public confidence and a serious violation of the public trust. Congress was quite correct to have banned insider trading and quite justified in more. Prior to Edmund Gettier, philosophers believed that knowledge was equivalent to justified true belief. Since Plato, it had generally been agreed among philosophers that there are three criteria of propositional.
About six months ago, I devoted a considerable amount of my time searching the Internet for an appropriate graduate school where I could utilize and advance my knowledge as well. We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. PhD Essay Technology Globalization Is war ever justified. Order original essay sample specially for your assignment needs. get custom essay. Are the Concerns over Globalization Justified? Essay type Research. Justified and Ancient: Analysis. Was the Atomic Bomb Dropped on Hiroshima Justified. Were the Allies Justified in Bombing German Cities? Justified wage for a worker. Why Congress is Justified in Banning Insider Trading. Knowledge and Justified True Belief. To Whom So Ever It May Concern.
Similar Topics 3d printing Internet Turkey Camera Face Recognition Plato Republic Italy Cyber Pakistan Determinism Life Philosophy Bangladesh Virtual Reality Alaska Africa Programming Egypt Cuba Argentina Humanism. Save time and let our verified experts help you.
Is WAR ever justified? - Dr Tim Jennings
, time: 5:04Is War Ever Morally Justified? - Words | Essay Example
War Is Never Justified War is never justified, this is a very diverse topic seeing as there can be so many opinions about it. I feel that war is never justified regardless of its purpose. There is no correct meaning for taking another human life, let alone taking thousands. War can never be a justified reason for all of the grieving families that have lost soldiers Apr 07, · Wars can be justified through the utilitarian theory and cost benefit analysis. These are dependent on whether the intention of the war is right and the cause for the war is just. Further, wars are only justified when other forms of conflict management have been tried and have failed. There are many types of war, however this essay will focus on military war in Estimated Reading Time: 7 mins Mar 27, · If the outcome of war brings more good than harm, war can be justified; even if the actual reason for war is not a morally acceptable one. Anything that, on a worldwide scale, improves the quality of life for the majority is acceptable
No comments:
Post a Comment